Using an Icom A-21 I have had several instances of transmitting a carrier but no audio. I am attributing this to poor connections with the headset adapter. I can see the transmit indicator on the LCD of the handheld but others do not always hear me. Wiggling the wires will restore the proper operation.
When working I usually get loud and clear reports on the ground. I have checked the radio on a communications monitor for proper freq and modulation, rx sensitivity and have checked my antenna with an antenna analyzer. The SWR is about 1.4 to 1 which is about right.
When I st checked out my chinese aviation headset I did get some RF feedback into the radio. The antenna is only like a foot from your headset. This caused a squeal in the audio even with the engine off and on the ground. This would change as one moved the wires around. I took the headset home and put a small capacitor across the mic element right in the mic itself this seems to have helped. I forgot the value of the cap but maybe a 220pf or 380pf small with leads soldered right on to the mic element.
Now I do get "I can barely understand you" reports from ATC at times (when under cruise condx) Other times it seems ok.
The sonex cockpit is very noisy. Some radios cope better and I think the MGL V6 might have one of the best. I think that a noise cancelling mic is a help. Noise cancelling on the electret mics is mostly a function of the mechanical construction of the mic housing. As I understand it the mic holder tries to let the ambient noise in the back with a small hole and the voice through the front. The difference between the voice and the ambient noise gets better (better S/N ration). I could be wrong I am not an engineer, nor did I stay at a Holiday Inn last night. I think I would benefit by adjusting the mic gain. On the Icom HT A-21 there is a mic gain and a modulation gain but they are internal adj and I have not tried them. Like I said they seem to be set perfect on the communications analyzer. I believe it might be beneficial to turn down the mic gain and this MIGHT yield a better S/N ratio. I think this is what happens with the MGL V-6.
As far as receiving I purchased a Headsets Inc. kit for my Chinese headset which replaces the speakers with 'real' electronic noise reduction units. When I turn this on the noise drops maybe 20db and I can actually understand everything on the radio. These are under $200 and work great.
http://www.headsetsinc.com/ANR_kits.htmlNext I may try the internal adj and turn the mic gain down a bit.
I think the ambient noise of the A/C is the main problem, if there is no RF getting into your wires, the antenna is ok with low SWR, the DC power is clean, try turning the mic gain down and talk loud to make up the diff, this will increase the S/N ratio on the xmit signal.
Try real ANR to help the receive, it makes a huge difference.
Let us know if you have any ideas....
Another idea is to built a cupless headset. More on this later..