lutorm wrote:I wish I knew more about what determines the octane needed. The Aerovee manual says you need 100LL to run 8.0 and can only run 7.0 on AKI 90 mogas. I think engines certified to run on 100LL commonly use 8.5 and what I've heard is that they have low detonation margin at full throttle. Yet my motorcycle has 11.3 compression and runs fine on AKI 89. What determines the difference? Does the Aerovee just have a really conservative knock margin?
Modern engines have things like fuel injection and variable valve timing to ensure better conditions in the cylinders. The AeroVee (and indeed your carbureted Lycomings and Continentals) have none of this. Also, motorcycle and automobile engines are only run at full power for very short bursts (i.e. when you accelerate up to speed) whereas aircraft engines are running continuously at max power - or close to it. Its just not an apples-to-apples comparison.
--Noel
P.S. The short answer to your question of "what determines octane needed" is a combination of: (a) How much do you need lead or another additive to aid in cylinder cooling, (b) how susceptible is the engine to knock/ping/detonation [and note that this is not a fixed value - its dependent upon the temperature of the cylinder head and the air-fuel mixture], and (c) what effects do the different types of fuel have on the overall stress and energy (i.e. pressure and temperature) on the moving components of the engine.