Nuckolls Crossbar Overvoltage Over Voltage

Discussion of aircraft electrical system design, construction, and problems.

Nuckolls Crossbar Overvoltage Over Voltage

Postby pschwenn » Sat Sep 16, 2017 1:56 am

Builders/Pilots

I would much appreciate diagnosis tips on the following:

I have an Aerovee in Xenos 32XS. It has a Bob Nucholls designed Crossbar Overvoltage Protection circuit that drives a yellow warning light and a 5A circuit breaker with manual reset that is supposed to clear the indicator. While taxiing the warning light came on and stayed on. The reset switch has no effect on the warning light. (That reset circuit breaker seems likely to be working properly, since neither disconnecting it or bridging it - for a split second - has any effect on the warning light.) This Overvoltage system apparently worked without incident from 2010 thru 2015

I wonder if someone has a suggestion about where to start: alternator failure, regulator failure, reset breaker, other?

My default plan is to replace the regulator and measure its output. Then measure the alternator output.

(I ran the engine a very short time with the yellow light on, and it sounded normal, restarted easily.) I didn't run the engine long enough to judge for certain whether the battery was charging. The battery is at a normal voltage: 13.0.)

Thank you for any suggestions.

(Associated question: I cannot remember whether the overvoltage yellow warning light always comes on with the master switches, and then sometime after the engine starts, it ordinarily goes out)?

Peter Schwenn
6514 41st Ave
University Park MD 20782

240-602-6931

N16XN under construction
N32SX @ KCGS (912iS being installed)
http://www.schwenn.com
Eaa4 - KCGS College Park MD
pschwenn
 
Posts: 25
Joined: Fri Jul 03, 2015 8:22 pm
Location: 6514 41st Avenue, University Park, MD 20782

Re: Nuckolls Crossbar Overvoltage Over Voltage

Postby kmacht » Sat Sep 16, 2017 7:40 am

Check the voltage coming out of the regulator. I had a regulator go on mine taking out the efis while flying. It stopped supplying dc and put a.c. into my electrical system. It was like turning the efis on and off hundreds of times a minute.

Keith
kmacht
 
Posts: 755
Joined: Tue Jun 21, 2011 11:30 am

Re: Nuckolls Crossbar Overvoltage Over Voltage

Postby sonex1374 » Sat Sep 16, 2017 9:19 am

Peter,

Is the crowbar activating? If it is, it's creating a dead short thru the crowbar module to ground, causing a massive rush of current thru the circuit breaker. This trips the breaker (the sole reason that breaker is even there), and the breaker tripping causes the regulator to disconnect from the bus. The warning light is there to help understand the state of the system, but the first thing in troubleshooting it to answer what/how the system is working.

A few questions first. When you turn on the master switch does the circuit breaker immediately trip? If it does trip, what happens if you manually reset the breaker? The light should only illuminate when the breaker trips, or does it light at other times? This will tell us if the light is properly indicating the state of the system.

Once you determine this part, the next step would be to disconnect the regulator output and see if the light comes on at all. You'll need to charge up your battery and go fly for a bit, again with the regulator output disconnected. Keep it under 30 min and your battery will be fine for this. If the system doesn't activate, it's likely it's working properly and when it is activating it's because the regulator output is too high of voltage.

At this point, it's merely a matter of figuring out why the regulator output is too high, and this could be due to poor grounding or an internally failed regulator that's not properly limiting the output voltage.

Keep in mind that if your regulator failed in a different way it wouldn't output anything at all (rather than a too-high voltage), but that won't trip the over voltage system.... your battery would just never stay charged.

Another possibility is that the light itself is failed, but not in the "burned out" sort of failed. The light is probably wired across the circuit breaker such that when the breaker is open the light illuminates. A short to ground on one wire of the light would cause it to light up all the time regardless of what the circuit breaker was doing. Look for chafing or strange contact in the wire leads to the light or maybe the light body itself (like accidentally grounding itself to the panel where it's mounted).

The final thing is that the circuit breaker could be failed internally and is permanently open inside, despite what it looks like on the outside. This can easily be checked with a multimeter across the two leads.

Try these things out and see if you can uncover the problem.

Jeff
Jeff Shultz
Sonex TD, 3300, AeroInjector
Kansas City, MO
http://www.sonex604.com
sonex1374
 
Posts: 605
Joined: Thu Mar 27, 2014 1:02 am

Re: Nuckolls Crossbar Overvoltage Over Voltage

Postby Darick » Sat Sep 16, 2017 4:26 pm

On a side but related note, did Bob Nuckolls finish his new regulator as mentioned in episode 21? Is it on B&C website?
Darick Gundy
Sonex #1646
N417DG
Taildragger, Aerovee, center stick, Prince P-Tip Prop
MGL E1, F2, V6 radio, Sandia Xponder, Reserve lift indicator (AOA), iFly 520
First flight! 10/21/2017
User avatar
Darick
 
Posts: 496
Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2013 9:39 pm
Location: PA


Return to Electrical System

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest