Manual Trim In a Onex

Discussion for builders, pilots, owners, and those interested in building or owning a Onex.

Manual Trim In a Onex

Postby WesRagle » Mon May 07, 2018 8:10 pm

Hi Guys,

I once had a Sonex. I loved the manual trim system. It was intuitive and quick. Just set the speed with the stick and trim off the pressure.
Question: Has anyone installed manual trim on a Onex? Pics?

Thanks,
Wes Ragle
Onex #89
Conventional Gear
Long Tips
Hummel 2400 w/Zenith Carb
Prince P Tip 54x50
First Flight 06/23/2020
42.8 Hrs. as of 10/30/21
WesRagle
 
Posts: 890
Joined: Fri Jan 05, 2018 12:35 pm
Location: Weatherford, Tx

Re: Manual Trim In a Onex

Postby PeterLovell » Fri May 11, 2018 6:54 am

I installed the factory dial a trim, works well but most of my flights are brief and constantly “mucking around “ . The stick forces are so light I just don’t play with the trim much,
Peter
Onex 120
PeterLovell
 
Posts: 13
Joined: Sun Dec 27, 2015 10:16 pm

Re: Manual Trim In a Onex

Postby WesRagle » Sat May 12, 2018 10:54 pm

Hi Peter,

Using trim in the pattern is ingrained in my mind. I like the speed set with no stick pressure. It just gives me a cue if I start flying off speed. I have seen videos of folks cranking on the Dial-a-Trim and it just looks like too much work, almost like a distraction. I understand the need on a Waiex but not on a conventional tail aircraft.
Wes Ragle
Onex #89
Conventional Gear
Long Tips
Hummel 2400 w/Zenith Carb
Prince P Tip 54x50
First Flight 06/23/2020
42.8 Hrs. as of 10/30/21
WesRagle
 
Posts: 890
Joined: Fri Jan 05, 2018 12:35 pm
Location: Weatherford, Tx

Re: Manual Trim In a Onex

Postby sonex1374 » Sat May 12, 2018 11:16 pm

I also enjoy the speed and ease of the standard trim tab and lever, and have no plans to change to anything different. However, the factory has commented previously that if you find yourself needing to crank too many turns on the "Dial-a-trim" knob in normal operations that you may need to adjust the springs for more tension. If anyone is unhappy with their dial-a-trim, perhaps this is a place to re-look.

Jeff
Jeff Shultz
Sonex TD, 3300, AeroInjector
Kansas City, MO
http://www.sonex604.com
sonex1374
 
Posts: 605
Joined: Thu Mar 27, 2014 1:02 am

Re: Manual Trim In a Onex

Postby dirkverdonck » Sun May 13, 2018 2:59 am

Hi,
I have added an external trim tab to the left side elevator, 85% size compared to the 'old' Sonex trim tab and operate it with a modified trim wheel from a Piper Pacer. In order to operate the tab with a single piano wire, I installed a reduced size copy of the elevator idler system and a tension spring behind the seat on the left side.
Haven't flight tested it yet as I only moved to the airport a couple of days ago but it operates as a normal, intuitive trim system; forward turn to push the nose down, turn backwards to raise the nose...
Dirk
Onex 117
Attachments
elevator trim 2.JPG
trim tab.JPG
Dirk Verdonck
Leffinge, Belgium
Onex #117
Taildragger, Aerovee 2.1, MGL iEFIS, TRIG radio and Transponder, electric flaps, external elevator trim, shortened wingtips, hydraulic brakes, hightened seat pan, extra inspection panels, etc
dirkverdonck
 
Posts: 88
Joined: Sun Sep 21, 2014 9:01 am
Location: Leffinge, Belgium

Re: Manual Trim In a Onex

Postby PeterLovell » Sun May 13, 2018 6:49 am

I certainly don’t need to crank the trim wheel, minor adjustment only needed to fly a circuit. I start my takeoff roll with the elevator absolutely neutral and it flies off in the 3 point attitude with no stick pressure. I have swapped to the 94 mm cylinders and high compression. At 80 kias I’m climbing at 1,000fpm or more, run up to 100+ knots downwind and always do glide/power off approaches at 70 kias on final, 65 over the fence and flare at 55 or less. Timed a circuit last week, take off to landing roll, 3 minutes,so trim not high on my priority list as stick pressures are never more then 2 fingers needed on the stick. Have I mentioned before that I love flying this plane!
Peter
PeterLovell
 
Posts: 13
Joined: Sun Dec 27, 2015 10:16 pm

Re: Manual Trim In a Onex

Postby Onex107 » Sun May 13, 2018 10:23 am

My experience exactly. I don't change the trim until I've added 10 gal of gas and am at cruise speed. Don't touch it until I've burned off 5 gal or until the next take off and cruise. A very small issue in a Onex.
OneX 107
N2107X
Onex107
 
Posts: 503
Joined: Mon Mar 24, 2014 6:44 pm
Location: Peoria, IL

Re: Manual Trim In a Onex

Postby WesRagle » Mon May 14, 2018 8:51 pm

Hi Peter,

I'll bet it is fun. Hope to find out myself one day.

As far as the trim is concerned, I'm sure you're right. After all you are in a position to know, I am not. I've never flown a Onex and never used a Dial-a-trim. Just thinking out loud, not always a good idea. Now that I think about it I do remember Drew commenting in his pattern work video that Onex flaps don't generate the pitching moment like the Sonex flaps.

As Dirk alludes to though, It would be nice if the knob rotated about the trim axis it was controlling. That would be better than left right, up down. Or is it right left, up down. Oh yea, it is like volume, right is up, left is down. Tongue firmly in cheek :-)

Wes

P.S. Looks interesting Dirk. Let us know how it works out.
Wes Ragle
Onex #89
Conventional Gear
Long Tips
Hummel 2400 w/Zenith Carb
Prince P Tip 54x50
First Flight 06/23/2020
42.8 Hrs. as of 10/30/21
WesRagle
 
Posts: 890
Joined: Fri Jan 05, 2018 12:35 pm
Location: Weatherford, Tx

Re: Manual Trim In a Onex

Postby dirkverdonck » Wed Sep 19, 2018 8:45 am

Hi Wes,
I have just under 30 hrs now on the Onex and I use the trim as follows: neutral for T/O and climb until flaps are up and rpm reduced to 3000.
Then just a trickle nose up trim to maintain 90 kias in the climb and when arriving at cruise alt, just a trickle down to maintain 110 kias.
Arriving back into the pattern, I reduce to below 90 kias, select 1/3 flaps , they are electrically operated via a screwjack, and a trickle nose up trim to maintain 80 kias during the descent, base 2/3 flaps and some nose up trim and on short final, full flaps and trim all the way up.
The trim system is very sensitive, only 1 full turn of the wheel from full nose down to full nose up, so some fingerspitzengefuhl is required!

I flew the "dial a trim" on a Sonex a couple of times and it took me all downwind to go from cruise to all nose up trim! This took way too long for my liking and the search for a better solution could begin.
I took some inspiration from very old Sonex plans which show an external trim tab and combined it with a proper trim wheel and an idler and a spring to avoid two cables to the trim tab.
Attachments
20180901_070220_resized.jpg
Dirk Verdonck
Leffinge, Belgium
Onex #117
Taildragger, Aerovee 2.1, MGL iEFIS, TRIG radio and Transponder, electric flaps, external elevator trim, shortened wingtips, hydraulic brakes, hightened seat pan, extra inspection panels, etc
dirkverdonck
 
Posts: 88
Joined: Sun Sep 21, 2014 9:01 am
Location: Leffinge, Belgium

Re: Manual Trim In a Onex

Postby WesRagle » Wed Sep 19, 2018 1:15 pm

Hi Dirk,

Sounds a lot like the Sonex with manual trim. The only difference was that I adjusted flaps and trim as soon as I turned final, no changes on short final. As far as one turn from nose up to nose down, the manual trim on a Sonex is only a few inches from full up to full down.

It was just so quick and easy. I remember I would just set the speed with the stick and then trim off the pressure. Then I would form a "doughnut" around the stick with my thumb and middle finger to verify hands off stable flight (70 MPH on final).

Dial-a-Trim makes sense to me in a Y tail or if center controls are wanted/needed. In the Onex I just don't get it.

If you have any pics of the routing of the trim cable out the back of the aircraft and/or part numbers for the trim cable (music wire) and cable housing I would find that helpful :-)

Wes

P.S. You should set up a contest to see which American can mess up the pronunciation of fingerspitzengefuhl the worst. Hint: Select contestants primarily from southern states.
Wes Ragle
Onex #89
Conventional Gear
Long Tips
Hummel 2400 w/Zenith Carb
Prince P Tip 54x50
First Flight 06/23/2020
42.8 Hrs. as of 10/30/21
WesRagle
 
Posts: 890
Joined: Fri Jan 05, 2018 12:35 pm
Location: Weatherford, Tx

Next

Return to Onex

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests